Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- Riffs on Numerical Themes
- John Bohannon
- Codebook
- Rudresh Mahanthappa Quartet (1)
- Pi Recordings, New York, 2006. CD. $14.
- On a recent frigid evening in New York City, I went downtown to hear some jazz. In most respects it was a perfectly normal concert: a quartet led by the saxophonist Rudresh Mahanthappa promoting a new CD in the sort of high-end jazz bar that seats about 100 people, all of them squinting in disbelief at the price of drinks. But there was also a tantalizing secret for those in the know. Mahanthappa composed the music for his latest album, Codebook, using number theory—the branch of mathematics that has born such fruits as the Fibonacci sequence (the inspiration for centuries of art and mysticism, including the best-selling if often reviled Da Vinci Code) and the tools of cryptography.
- One could say that mixing math and music is nothing new. As the German philosopher Gottfried Leibniz put it, “Music is the pleasure the human mind experiences from counting without being aware that it is counting.” But whereas all music is built to some extent on mathematical structures, Mahanthappa takes the relationship to the next level: Math isn't just the medium of his art, it is also his subject.
- Figure
- View larger version:
- In this window
- CREDIT: JOE SUTLIFF
- Take for example his tune “Further and In Between.” The melodies batted between sax, bass, and piano are permutations of a scale built on the semitone intervals (1,4,2,8,5,7). It happens that 142,857 is one of the so-called cyclical numbers, which have long fascinated number theorists and numerologists alike (not to conflate the two). Cyclical numbers with n digits have the interesting property that multiplying one of them by a whole number between 1 and n generates a new number having the same digits rearranged (e.g., 142857 × 3 = 428571). Mahanthappa uses this arithmetical curiosity as a constraint for improvisation: play anything as long as it generates a cyclical number.
- But what does the audience get out of such mathematical mischief? The pessimist in me says that they get nothing at all, that it's just a gimmick. Let's call that the null hypothesis. If you've been to modern art museums, you'll know immediately what I mean. (Leaning forward to read the artist's explanation of the pile of tin cans covered in panty hose and melted bubble gum, you learn that it represents spacetime, evolution, artificial intelligence, etc.)
- To test the null hypothesis, I gave Mahanthappa the best chance possible to prove it wrong by assembling an ideal audience. Sitting around the table with me were two musicians with no formal mathematical training, a mathematician with no musical training, a couple of mathematicians who are also accomplished musicians, and, as a control group, a lawyer and a social worker. I passed around a cheat sheet so that everyone knew what to listen for. (The day before the concert, I met with Mahanthappa and wrote down the order of the pieces to be played and the mathematical basis of each.) The lights dimmed, the band mounted the stage, and the experiment began.
- Mahanthappa launched us into the deep end right away, both musically and mathematically. Before the rest of the instruments joined, he broke the silence with a sequence of notes so fast and jittery it was like a spider dancing on his sax. The manic melodies of the tune, “The Decider,” are a mapping of the Fibonacci sequence (2) onto the 12-tone musical scale. From that initial shock, the band carried the piece aloft in what felt like a series of booster rockets before reaching the seemingly free-floating (but actually quite structured) space of improvisational jazz.
- Using the Fibonacci sequence seems like an arbitrary choice, perhaps verging on a gimmick. Wouldn't a random sequence do just as well? According to Mahanthappa, the choice rises above gimmickry for two reasons. For one, he says, taking the sequence as his inspiration and constraint generates music he could not have produced otherwise. For another, he claims, the mapped sequence has unique musical behaviors. “It sounds right no matter what key the others are comping (3) in,” he told me. “I tried alternative sequences and they didn't have that property.”
- Fair enough. However, such subtleties didn't immediately come across to my test audience. “The mathematical themes are diff icult to hear,” remarked Michael Thaddeus (an algebraic geometer at Columbia University) with furrowed brow. “Well, it is called Codebook after all,” he quipped. And for some of the pieces—such as “Frontburner,” in which a Coltrane melody has been run through several layers of encryption—no human ear, no matter how prepared, would be able to detect Mahanthappa's invention.
- Far more apparent than any of the individual mathematical tropes was an overall sense of lush complexity. “The drummer in particular was using rhythmic elements from Indian classical music in a way that was clearly far beyond that of an amateur,” observed Manjul Bhargava, a number theorist (and tabla performer) at Princeton University. (Indeed, the drummer, Dan Weiss, is a student of the renowned Calcutta tabla player Samir Chatterjee.)
- But as the show went on, mathematical neurons did begin to fire. Thaddeus deduced that the melodies in “Further and In Between” get their jumpy quality from the lack of consecutive digits in the cyclical numbers. He and Bhargava were also wise to the math within another tune, “Enhanced Performance,” which is built on a nested set of accelerating polyrhythms. (Mahanthappa dedicated the piece to steroid use among Olympic athletes, and knowing this contributed an extra squirt of adrenaline.) Nor did you have to be a mathematician (or a musician) to observe many of the tricks. Caroline Trowbridge, a recent graduate of Yale Law School, easily detected that layered within several of the tunes—but especially “Play It Again Sam,” dedicated to Samuel Morse—were the performers' names in Morse code, like signatures on sound paintings.
- So on this basis, I can already rule out the null hypothesis. The math is definitely more than just a gimmick, even to the untrained ear. But what then does the audience get out of the experience? This is where the experiment got interesting. The band played two sets, and the breather between them, like a coffee break between lectures at a good scientific conference, brimmed with heated, cross-disciplinary conversation. Topics ranged from how constraints act as dynamos for creativity (for example, the sonnet form in poetry) and the biological constraints that produce Fibonacci numbers in nature to the independent discovery (far earlier than in Europe) and use of Fibonacci numbers in ancient Indian poetry. With our brains fizzing from such cross-talk, the second set was all the more enjoyable.
- And that supports my alternative hypothesis for what an audience can get out of a Mahanthappa performance: a unique, jazzfueled occasion to explore ideas. Trowbridge called it “the secret knowledge effect”—that heightening of the senses from an awareness of hidden layers of meaning—and I agree. In addition, the quartet's virtuosity makes their playing a pleasure to behold, no matter how one feels about jazz. But before taking my word for it, I recommend replicating the experiment for yourself—with the CD if you can't catch a performance.
- ↵1. The quartet comprises Rudresh Mahanthappa, Vijay Iyer, François Moutin, and Dan Weiss
- ↵2. The sum of each pair of consecutive numbers in the Fibonacci sequence [0, 1, 1, 2, 3, 5, 8, 13, 21, …] generates the next. The ratios of consecutive Fibonacci numbers [½, 2/3, 5/8, 8/13, …] converge on the irrational number Φ, (0.618033989…), known as the golden mean
- ↵3. That's jazz-speak for “accompanying.”
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment