Foal's Play Part 2

>Day murderous activity in Equestria
>You wake up to a clanking and swishing sound
>You open your eyes and notice you're back on the bed
>It smells like sweat and hay
>Ewww
>You see Sweetie Bell putting a tray on your nightstand
>The tray has what seems to be a balanced breakfast
>Only all of it is burnt
>Even the juice in the glass is just ash
>Fluttershy stands over you with her front two hooves
>"Oh Anon look what she did for you! Aw that's so sweet!"
>Sweetie Bell looks at you with a sad face
>"I'm sorry I didn't listen to you last night. I wanted to make it up to you by making breakfast!"
Thank you Sweetie Bell.
>"Well?"
What?
>"Aren't you gonna eat it silly?"
>Oh shit she really wants you to?
>Fuuuck
>Time to take one for the team
>You eat all of the burnt stuff
>She smiles brightly and runs out
>Fluttershy snuggles close to you
>"Is burnt food your fetish?"
>You stare at her
No. That was awful and I only ate it to give her satisfaction.
>"You could have just said you weren't feeling well..."
>Fucking Burnt food...
>You get up and stretch
>Fluttershy slaps your ass with a wing
WATCH YOURSELF SHY.
>She giggles and flies off to the bathroom
Fucking Fluttershy...
>You walk out into the hallway and go downstairs
>You see the trail of ash she made when she brought that horrid food to you
>You still have no idea how you managed to not throw up on her
>You sit on the couch and read the paper from yesterday
>You put it down when you notice the doll talking
>Why does Rainbow have one of those anyway?
>It's creepy as shit...
>"So Jamie what do you think about Anon's house?"
>"It's 20% cooler now that I'm here!"
Hey Sweetie Bell.
>She looks over at you
How much can this thing say?
>"Only three sentences...but mine's special! Like last night he told me his full name and a whole bunch of other stuff!"
>You stopped paying attention after sentences
Huhwhat? Oh that's cool Sweetie!
>She believes you were listening and continues playing with the doll
>Fluttershy comes and sits next to you
>"She's so innocent isn't she?"
>You nod
>Fluttershy rests her head on your lap
Fluttershy I feel like I was supposed to do something today...
>She lifts her head up eye level to you
>"Me?"
>You push her face away
Nice try. But no something for someone.
>She puts a hoof to her chin
>Her eyes shrink to pinpricks and she starts sweating
>"OHMYGOODNESSIHAVETOFEEDMYANIMALS!"
>Then she flies out
Hmmm...
>You walk over to the calendar
>On today it says: "Dentist Appointment."
>You look back at Sweetie Bell
>She plays with toys as the doll is...reading your paper
>You walk over and take it from the doll
Why did you give the doll my paper Sweetie Bell?
>"I didn't."
Don't play stupid with me...
>She looks at you with innocent eyes
>Fuck
Anyways...I have to go to a dentist appointment so I'm gonna call over someone to watch you okay?
>She nods and takes the doll back over and talks to it
>She sure has some imagination
>There's a knock on the door
>You open it
>It's Lyra
>"Hey Anon, was just in the neighborhood and thought I'd stop by...you know maybe hang out?"
>The whole time she stares at your hands
Actually you could help me...
>"Oh really?! How?"
Can you watch Sweetie Bell until I get back?
>She nods and trots in
Just make yourself at home. And Sweetie Bell!
>She looks at you
You listen to what miss Lyra says okay?
>"Okay Anon!"
>You head out to the dentist


>You are Lyra
>Goodness his hands are amazing...
>They just make everything so much easier to do
>It's like our tools were meant for them!
>You look at Sweetie Bell
I'm gonna go to the washroom okay?
>"Okay."
>You get up and walk up the stairs
>It's a good thing you stalk Anon almost all the time or else you wouldn't even know where his bathroom was
>You open the door and stand in front of the mirror
>Only the top of your eyes is on it
>You stand on your hind legs with your front ones on the sink
Oh goodness I've never actually been in here before...
>You get off the sink and look at the trash bin
>Tissues? Are those his TISSUES?!
>You squee and stick your head in the basket
>You sniff them and shudder in ecstacy
>Then you feel a sharp pain in your back leg
>You pull out and turn around
>The doll lays there
Sweetie Bell...
>You pick the doll up with your mouth and head to the stairs
>Then you feel a stinging pain across your neck
>Blood pours out and you fall over
>You see the doll standing over you with a razor
>Everything goes black



>You are Anon
>After one painful hour of Colgate jabbing things in your mouth, you finally get to go home
>As you pull out the keys to unlock your door Fluttershy zooms over
>"My gosh they were so hungry! Um Anon why are you out here?"
I had a dentist appointment.
>"So you left Sweetie Bell alone in the house?"
No I had Lyra watch her until I got back. I was only gone an hour what's the worst that could happen?
>You open the door and see Sweetie Bell playing with the doll...still
You really love that thing huh?
>She nods with a big smile
Where's miss Lyra?
>"She said she needed to go to the washroom. Isn't that funny? She calls it a 'washroom' hahaha!"
>You chuckle and head up the stairs
Lyra? I'm back now you can go home.
>You open the door
>Both you and Fluttershy scream at the gashed open body corpse in a bathtub full of blood
>Fast forward
>The guards and investigators had come over and interrogated the shit out of everything
>There's even one staring a plant down
>Wat
>Fluttershy sits next to you wrapped in a towel shaking as they bring the body out with a body bag
>You put an arm around her to comfort her
>A guard has been asking you questions for the past 30 minutes
>"Sir. This makes no sense. How could she have done it herself?"
Well you tell me a better reason! The only one here was...
>You and Fluttershy say in unison
"Sweetie Bell..."
>Fluttershy trembles
>"No Anon...I don't want to think that that sweet little foal did something like this...no she couldn't have!"
>She begins rocking back and forth
>"No...maybe some vicious monster from the Everfree broke in and did it..."
>She leans into you and cries on your shirt
>The guard is about to ask another question when Sweetie Bell comes downstairs and sits in front of you
>"Fluttershy...Anon..."
>You both look at her
>"I'm sorry for what Jamie did..."
>You put your fingers on the bridge of your nose
Sweetie Bell...a DOLL did not do this.
>"He's not a doll! He moves and talks just like we do!"
>The guard picks up one of Sweetie Bell's hooves
Hey what are you-
>You all three of you see the dried blood
>You just stare at her in disbelief
>"I was playing with the toys and Jamie came back. We played patty cake and I guess I didn't notice..."
>The guard pulls her towards him
>You stand up and punch him in the face
ALL OF YOU GET THE FUCK OUT OF MY HOUSE!
>They disperse rather quickly
>Sweetie sits next to Fluttershy and rests her head on her lap
>"Jamie-"
ENOUGH ABOUT THAT STUPID DOLL! YOU GO UPSTAIRS TO BED WITHOUT ANOTHER WORD! AM I CLEAR?!
>Cowers on the other side of Fluttershy
>Fluttershy doesn't even care
DID YOU HEAR ME?! BECAUSE I CAN BE LOUDER!
>"I heard you!"
>She runs up the stairs and slams the guest door shut
>Fluttershy slowly gets up and goes into the kitchen
>You watch from the couch as she makes soup
>She makes three bowls
>"Anon. I'm going to bring her back down here and we're gonna talk like adults."
>She walks upstairs
>Holy shit you just got bossed around by Fluttershy...
>You get up and sit at the table
>Where the biggest bowl is
>Because fuck the police
>Sweetie Bell comes down...with that doll
>It's feet have crusted blood on it as well
>You slightly shake your head
>She sits at the table and puts the doll next to her
>She doesn't look at you or Fluttershy
>Fluttershy makes a gestures you to talk to her
Sweetie Bell...
>She looks at you
>"Don't hurt me please..."
>"Aw..."
Shhh Fluttershy. Sweetie Bell I'm not going to hurt you. But you do understand that lying is bad right?
>"Yeah...but I didn't lie! I was telling the truth!"
>"Sweetie Bell don't raise you voice please."
Can you stop pretending that doll is real for a few minutes please?
>She pouts
>"I already told you...he is real! And stop calling him a doll. His NAME IS JAMIE!"
>With that she picks up the doll and storms upstairs
Fuck...
>You put your head in your hands
>Fluttershy's wing rubs your shoulder
>"It's okay babe...is failure your fetish?"
>You smack away the wing and she moans a bit
Fluttershy you really have no idea when to ask this stuff...
>You finish your soup and put the bowl in the sink
>Fluttershy finishes her soup and puts Sweetie Bell's soup in the microwave
You know it's hard to discipline a kid if one of us is the "Good" one.
>You point to the soup
>"Well she can't just go hungry Anon! You should have seen how fast she scarfed down the food last night! And how happy she was..."
Okay I guess...but let me give it to her so she doesn't completely hate me.
>Fluttershy smiles and pushes a time in with her nose
>How she does it, you don't care
>She flies up the stairs and goes into your room
>Having Flutters around isn't really that bad actually...
>It's her damn fetish guessing attempts
>The microwave dings and you bring the soup up to her room
>You open the door
Sweetie Bell I have some food f-
>You stop when you don't see her anywhere and one of the windows is open
>You drop the bowl of soup and it shatters
>You frantically look under the bed and in the closet
>Fluttershy flies in
>"I heard a noise, what happened?"
Sweetie Bell is gone!
>You stick your head out the window
>Blankets were tied together and to the window frame for her to get down with
Fluttershy she isn't here!
>You run downstairs and outside with Fluttershy in pursuit
>You both run through town screaming Sweetie Bell's name
>Twilight sees you both looking scared
>"Oh damnit what happened now?"
>She still remembers the time when Angel ran away in terror because you farted on the couch next to him
>Hehe
>"Sweetie Bell is missing! She tied a bunch of blankets together and left from Anon's window!"
>Twilight puts on sunglasses
>"Mother of Celestia..."
Twilight quit fucking around and help us find her!
>She nods and runs with you screaming Sweetie Bell's name
>Fuck you hope she's okay



>You are Sweetie Bell
>Jamie told you he knew of a place you could get away from that meanie face Anon
>On the outskirts of town there is a junkyard
>He told you to go there
>So you did
>He said you were going to have tons of fun
>You sit on a chair on the top of a mound of not so stinky trash
Hey Jamie! Look at me! I'm the Queen of the junkyard!
>You look around but you don't see him
>He must have run off to do something
>You should just stay here and keep watch for Anon and Fl-
>You see them approaching
>They don't see you
>You slump out of the chair and stick your head out to watch them as they search through the piles of trash
>Twilight pokes Anon
>"Do you REALLY think she'd be in a dump?!"
>"Well where the fuck else can we look, we've searched the whole town!"
>She huffs and continues levitating trash
>He must really want to beat you now
>You sneeze and Anon hears it
>"This way!"
>They trudge up the side of the mountain of trash
>You try to back up but you can't
>Your eyes meet Anon's
>"I found her!"
>He pulls you from the trash pile and spins around with you
>Then he pulls you in for...a hug?
Why are you hugging me?
>"I was so worried you'd gone and gotten yourself taken...or killed even!"
>You smile at his kindness
Wait a minute! I need to find-
>There is an explosion behind you
>A old seemingly abandoned house exploded
>All of you just watch in confusion
>Then you see Jamie
>You jump out of Anon's arms and run to him
Jamie!
>You pick him up by the mouth and carry him back up to Anon
>Twilight smiles kinda creepily
>"You have a doll too?! I thought I was the only one..."
>You toss him over your head and he lands on your back
He's not a doll! His name is Jamie.
>Her ears flatten
>"Oh...sorry. Jamie."
>You head back into town
>Fluttershy and Anon mumble in the rear while you and Twilight talk about fun stuff you do with Jamie
And last night he told me his full name and a whole bunch of other stuff!
>"What's his full name?"
I think it was...James Lee Hay.
>Fluttershy gasps and faints while Anon catches her
>Twilight's eye's widen
>"You shouldn't joke about him!"
Jamie? What's wrong with him?
>Twilight sighs and looks back to Anon carrying Fluttershy
>Anon nods
>"James Lee Hay was a strangler...he killed many p0nies before dying...I don't ever want to hear you say his name again. Okay?"
>You nod
>Why doesn't everyp0ny believe you?!
>You get home and Twilight leaves
>When you get back in your room Anon takes nails and drives them into the window frame to prevent you from opening them again
I'm sorry Anon...
>Fluttershy is picking up pieces of something and scrubbing the floor
>"You just get some rest Sweetie Bell. You have school in the morning."
Can I bring Jamie?!
>He looks at you angrily
>Then he sighs
>"Sure."
>Fluttershy finishes cleaning whatever that was on the ground and they both head back to his room
>You wonder what they do in there as you drift off to sleep