OKAY. Like I said already today, I've been doing other stuff today and have no been focused in on re-evaluating after the two recent flips. In particular I've been meaning to read more of Gerry because I really haven't looked into his content much; we were never active together until the very end of the day yesterday and my attention was elsewhere.

Claire - As I explained, Claire has not been playing the same game she was the previous two games where she flipped town. In fact, this game she's been acting like one of the players she would likely be complaining about in previous games. Her content is lackluster at best and the only redeeming posts she made where at the very end of the day under heavy pressure but in retrospect I can look past that. I was thinking at the time that I would of expected a PR claim from her but on the other hand I had previous pointed out reasons why I was fairly sure she actually wasn't a PR so perhaps she was adverse to doing so. She lacks logical progression. For example; she follows me voting SirSlick and then turned on a dime and criticizes me for making a read based on one post (something of a misunderstanding but it would be a legitimate thought nonetheless) and then proceeds to do exactly what she had just condemned by reading me based on one post. Her attitude today hasn't really convinced me otherwise but in fairness I haven't given much up until now today either in terms of hard content. Also she hammered the fricking alignment cop.

My read on Transcend, as I have explained, has been turbulent. He's acted anti-town and just annoying in a lot of ways, and while I don't see that as necessarily alignment telling (especially with Soda), I did feel it was a good justification for him to be the d1 lynch over Stove, which I pointed out yesterday. There was one point early on where I really felt I had caught him out and started pushing on him and reaction just felt awful but later on rereading him, while I was still disappointed with his actions, his general tone of his content and posts felt towny. Either way I was still willing to lynch him and only started looking elsewhere purely because it was clear he wasn't getting voted. Also maybe it's naive of me to say so but townpoints for pointing out why we shouldn't vote Stove and then not voting Stove.

Sincerely: She had something of a slow start imo (though perhaps I felt that way because I wasn't there at the start) but after I applied a bit of pressure on her I actually saw some really good towntells. I explained this earlier as well but essentially when reading Sincerely I tend to see a lot of things I just don't see scum saying. She's someone who I feel is somewhat careful about the words she uses so a genuine vs faked logical progression is even more pronounced in her. I pointed this out in one post in particular which was the "read I made based on one post" but it carried through the rest of the game. Also near the end of d1 she was bleeding town and was clearly thinking things through thoroughly unlike people who were just "uhg idk vote stove i guess." Not surprised at her reveal in the slightest.

Antikrist I scumread (I was wrong whoops) because she had this really awkward, unexplained vote on Claire which I felt in context was just bad bad bad bad bad. In retrospect I can see she probably just didn't think it through at the time and I can appreciate just wanted to throw a vote up and call it a day but I, like you Stragger, expect more from people here and forced her to actually defend herself and put some thought into her play. Hindsight is 20/20 of course and I honestly don't know if I would of maintained my antikrist scumread through today. It was very much a "heat of the moment" push. I saw a scummy move and I capitalized on it.

SirSlick: My initial read on this guy was that jumping in out of nowhere and suggesting we lynch the ISP was a scummy move and I called him out for it. But having seen that somehow the majority of our town went along with it, I don't know if I can maintain that read. I'm seriously disappointed that Stove got lynched if it's not obvious by now. Outside of that he's been unremarkable but I really haven't seen him ever towntell so he definitely leans scum for me. Other people followed the vote out of laze; he started the push because he was looking to have some kind of read imo and he went with the easiest pick (I outlined why scum will tend to push on ISPer's d1).

I'll give more later but I seriously feel like my head is about to explode and it's 1am and I have shit to do.