For brevity, Bear's content will be quoted in this bin with a > behind it to represent it.

>https://epicmafia.com/game/4593020/review
>
>Becameclear is town, Cridi is nilla. The only thing Cridi does D1 is hardclaim sheriff and ask for a vest. Obviously, he gets >shot. CharcoalDragon calls out Becameclear on it, and his reaction is quite particular.
>2GunTommy is a 2k+ account in competitive for no good reason. In this game, D1, he implies sheriff should be vested - But at >night, he convinces his partner to go for sheriff instead of trying to find BS. 2GunTommy hooks sheriff and kills the cop, getting >lynched in 5 way. It might not seem like much from 2GunTommy, but we will look more into him in other games.

Cridi's behaviour as mafia is to claim sheriff in every single comp game he played this round. (https://epicmafia.com/game/4599982/review as one example) Becameclear hard-pushes Pain here not 2Gun. If 2Gun is throwing for him, he either doesn't know about it or isn't taking advantage of it. Either way, this isn't enough to suggest cheating.

>https://epicmafia.com/game/4593176/review
>
>Becameclear is nilla, Cridi is town. D1, the only thing Cridi does is talk about last game. There's something particular about >this: When Cridi is mafia and Becameclear is town, Cridi always CC's sheriff in an attempt to get shot. I feel like this is an >important point in Cridi's behavior.
>D2, he just brb's during the cop CC, and only returns to claim last blue after the other one is shot. He outs no reads during the >entire day. D3, he claims the cop, Becameclear's CC, slipped. He pushes on him. It's really the only read he outs all game. After >game, he doesn't comment on losing, or being wrong.

Re-sheriff ccing is something Cridi always does. Cridi pushing Became's cc is potentially playing in his favour, but this is the only representation of Cridi actually doing it in Bear's entire pastebin. (Making it irrelevant)

>https://epicmafia.com/game/4599958/review
>
>What is important about this game is that Becameclear shows he KNOWS Cridi is throwing for him, during timestamps 10:35 - 10:38. >At first, he seems amused, and then, he adds a delayed reaction to it, saying he would get banned because of him. However, he >never makes real effort to dodge him, despite what Ailuropoda tells him. This alone should be enough evidence to deem his run >invalid. He has knowlege of Cridi throwing for him, but he does no real effort to stop it, tell the mods, or even avoid him in >games - Which means he's taking advantage of it. He says he's gonna get banned because of it, acknowledging it's a bad thing, >however, he continues playing with Cridi.

Re-Cridi wasn't throwing for him. Cridi's behaviour as mafia is consistent in games with and without became in them. Furthermore, Becameclear only play 1 completed game with Cridi after this. How is he 'not trying to dodge him'?

>https://epicmafia.com/game/4599956/review
>
>Becameclear and Ineedtime are town, Cridi is hooker. D1, he hardclaims sheriff again, gets shot. While this happens, Ineedtime >does not speak at all, so they never overlap when they're speaking. He becomes fully active after Cridi is dead, curiously enough.
>This time, gallagher has a different reaction to Cridi being shot. They kill Becameclear, who fakeclaimed BS, turning it into auto >for town.
>D2, Ineedtime laughs at Becameclear being killed, fully knowing he was blue, automatically knows who maf is between BS claims, and >he also knows the lawyer.

gallagher actually followed Messere's read here. And yeah, Ineed knew mafia. That was because Ineed is likely the same person as Cridi. There is no signs of any involvement of Became here.

>https://epicmafia.com/game/4593051/review
>
>Becameclear, 2GunTommy and italemi
>
>Becameclear is shot D1 by sheriff. N1, 2GunTommy finds lawyer, and is killed that night. D2, "italemi" only foses BorynStone, who >2GunTommy had checked before dying, and obviously turned up guilty.
>D3, italemi knows Sherlock is BS and instavotes antikrist with no issues, then flips to BorynStone. MikeyRu could've been mafia >there, but italemi never considers it at all.
>In 3 way, italemi quickvotes last mafia.

italemi scumreads anti/Boryn/Sherlock day 1. Him knowing BS is a little sus but once again, nothing damning. His reads remained consistent from day 1. The mafia outside his 2/3 was hammered which is why they were accurate.
Even if he was cheating, which I heavily doubt, there's no evidence of Becameclear's involvement.

>Becameclear, Deathlaser, TheChubbyNerd
>
>https://epicmafia.com/game/4590309/review
>
>If we analyze both Deathlaser AND TheChubbyNerd, then we've found a pattern: Inactive for months, comes back, plays a couple of >Fancy Pants games and then goes to comp with Becameclear. However, Deathlaser only played this game
>(https://gyazo.com/cb7a870abcc1809727260bff28d9f8fa), while TheChubbyNerd also played two other comp games
>(https://gyazo.com/7e429a19bc67c65f31eb2bf5a212ddb0). They both disappear after this game.

I'll completely disregard this point since Deathlaser is a vet I used to play with, and is therefore not a ghost account.

To summerise Bear's points:->reason they're invalid
Cridi always claims sheriff as mafia when Became is town: Cridi always claims sheriff as mafia throughout the round. Became always flipped town when Cridi flipped mafia.
Became didn't dodge Cridi after showing clear signs of knowing he was throwing for him: Became only played 4 total games (only 1 after acknowledging that), which does show signs of dodging unless my brain is a little messed up. (And only 2 total games with Ineedtime)
Became cheated with ghost account 2GunTommey etc.: There's not enough here to suggest that this account (or the others) were even cheating let alone that it/they threw for Became.
"Even if it wasn't cheating his run should be invalidated": 4 games is DEFINITELY not enough to invalidate a run.

Cheers. Abe.