Abdullah Gondal YQ

Yasir Qadhi seeing such a frustrating and derogatory post from you was unexpected.

How do you know that everything that is illogical or not being able to be explained by logic becomes Supra rational. How do you distinguish between illogical and irrational from Supra rational. This seems like an unfounded assertion. And a really bad one.

There are many ideas in Islam that are irrational. For example the idea of eternal torture in the afterlife. The concept of slavery or the harsh punishments. The dillema of worshipping an Omnipotent God who doesn't need worship. The whole concept of blind belief in gand claims without any evidence at all.

What ideas are Supra rational? Is the belief that shooting stars are missiles thrown at jins by angels for eavesdropping on heavenly conversations a Supra rational belief? Or is the belief that Muhammad rode a beast to heaven to meet God just like a multitude of similar stories from other religions also Supra rational? Or is the hatred towards homosexual people and them being executed a Supra rational idea too?

You seem to generalize all murtads under the same brush. You don't tackle the arguments rather attack their person and commit the ad hominem fallacy. Many arguments I myself have established have nothing to do with the previous paragraph. They are derived from studying the seerah of Muhammad and reading the Quran from a critical angle. The idea that is the Quran perfectly preserved. How can we trust the idea of Hadith and not question bukhari when you find such incidents in the book. https://sunnah.com/bukhari/63/75
One can also question the Qurans grand and miraculous claims and why we see no evidence of them. Perhaps there are many philosophical issues with burden of proof or the Russel's teapot. What infinite wisdom is behind God torturing us pesky little indefensible humans for finite crimes with infinite torture. Or why is life a test when God is omniscienct or that how can a God be all loving and merciful yet come across as megalomaniac that wants to be worshipped and loved and if you don't give him what he wants he will torture you. The problem of evil is another issue.

No life isn't the most depressing without God. Instead it can be very liberating. It can be much more fun. You don't have to worry about someone constantly watching you. Plugging God in to satisfy your desire to exist after your death doesn't make the idea of God true nor give any real meaning to life. What is the Qurans view on life's purpose? To worship an omnipotent God so he doesn't torture you? That's really naive and shallow.

Proof for God is screaming at them? Which God? The deistic God it the God of personal Theism? Or Allah amongst the thousands of other God's in human history. An invisible being that allegedly exists on a throne outside space time?
Our subjective concious experience can be made better or worse and we can give purpose and meaning to our own lives, for example reducing unncessaru suffering for other sentient beings.

It's really sad you say deaf dumb and blind. But why did you stop there? Please tell us about Allah's other insults towards disbelievers too that they are najs, like cattle, worse creation ever, worse than animals, like dogs donkeys etc.

What is ironic after pumping the Supra rational and calling murtdaeen as emotionally and physcologicaly motivated you use an example of an individual suffering emotional and phsycological trauma of losing a parent as a rational and intellectual point for returning to Islam. It's unbelievable to see the hypocrisy at display here.

To enjoy the blessings of the next life? Why should I accept that an invisible afterlife exists with a heaven and hell that we have no evidence for? Or that thousands of religions have made the same claim? Not too mention the philosophical implications that can arise from such absurd beliefs. You know the elves also go to Valanor or middle Earth after they die.

Would have expected something better from a scholar like yourself. Please remember that Islam isn't special and suffers from the same fundamental errors other religions do. People can and do leave it for intellectual reasons. The "arguments" you presented to defend your faith have been and are used by other religions to defend them.