Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- ------------
- 1. SUMMARY
- ------------
- TL;DR: Hikaru is responsible to almost delete Chessbrah's youtube channel.
- On date 7th April 2021, Eric from Chessbrah replied doing a livestream explaining the situation and attacking Hikaru.
- This escalated a sequence of events, like Chessbae's "deletion", people sharing past Hikaru stories, etc.
- * GMHikaru's youtube channel did 2 copyright strikes on videos from Chessbrah's channel. (Clip: https://clips.twitch.tv/ScrumptiousComfortablePelicanFloof-wjlU6fWdu4oBOCV6 )
- - The two videos taken down (now up again) are the following:
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=davarlKjOFs
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lpknYa3N44E
- * Eric made a live stream explaining the situation (Full VOD: https://www.twitch.tv/videos/978764250 )
- - During the live stream, Eric attacked Hikaru and Chessbae (Hikaru's current manager and former Chessbrah's twitch channel moderator).
- Some people think Eric was pretty toxic on the video. Some people think this is just a counter-attack, justified by Hikaru's treat to destroy Chessbrah's youtube channel
- - Eric said that Hikaru would remove the strikes only if they don't show Hikaru in a "negative light". (Clip: https://clips.twitch.tv/CautiousLovelyMonitorTheRinger-euVluiwzXFMlQnsS ) Eric refused.
- - Hikaru replied to "Why do you have a beef with Eric?" question with:
- "Eric is that guy that drinks and offended xQc and Botez". (CLIP DELETED BY HIKARU)
- Other notes:
- * HIKARU/CHESSBAE COMPLETELY DELETED 7th APRIL 2021 VOD AND CLIPS FROM TWITCH.
- - Yes is true that Eric heavily offended Botez and xQc. Yes, he was drunk. Yes, he apologized even though he said what he did was inexcusable.
- - GMHikaru's youtube channel posted the same kind of "double reaction" video BEFORE Chessbrah's channel did. GMHikaru's channel did not ask for permission. GMHikaru's youtube channel deleted those videos before striking Chessbrah's "double reaction" video.
- - The copyright strikes were lifted during the Eric's twitch rant.
- - r/chess megathread
- https://www.reddit.com/r/chess/comments/mmonqa/megathread_2_april_8_hikaru_nakamura_eric_hansen
- - There is no Hikaru side of the story. He is staying silent. (He literally doesn't even care.)
- (2021-04-12 Edit: He did a tweet)
- -----------------------------
- 2. TITLED PLAYERS REACTIONS
- (post 7th April stuff)
- -----------------------------
- - GM Daniel "Danya" Naroditsky on the accident
- https://livestreamfails.com/clip/112003
- - GM Hess on Hikaru
- https://clips.twitch.tv/ColdTentativeCheddarKeyboardCat-jJP6U_g6C0_sPQSA
- - GM Andrew Tang on when Hikaru accused him of cheating
- https://clips.twitch.tv/SpineyStrangeTardigradeNotATK-1hPV0Il-fknDPEzE
- - Eric says to do research on Hikaru stories, and that most titled players stays quiet to avoid potential repercussions
- https://clips.twitch.tv/DreamyCrepuscularOysterYee-mFyQHHF1LJVASCdO
- - GM Ben Finegold on Hikaru (long but full of stories)
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=21mHkRNrN_Y&t=295s
- --------------------------
- 3. HIKARU PAST STORIES
- (pre 7th April stuff)
- --------------------------
- - GM David Howell describes his run-in with Hikaru after he drew him. Hikaru says David was "very F'ing lucky" and had "No F'in understanding" Hikaru's father apologizes for his son; Hikaru was 27 at the time.
- https://clips.twitch.tv/EnchantingCourteousFriesPrimeMe
- - GM John Bartholomew on Hikaru
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-LKZpaVqJGk&t=4510s
- - IM ChessExplained vs Hikaru, Hikaru gets salty
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ax4m0nrIe3w&t=241s
- - GM Hansen vs Hikaru, Hikaru gets salty
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nSayvtBxTmg&t=558s
- - Hikaru accuses other players of cheating:
- https://www.reddit.com/r/chess/comments/bgwi2o/naka_after_losing_thinking_engine_was_used/
- https://www.reddit.com/r/chess/comments/4l2ey3/hikaru_nakamura_accusing_akshat_chandra_of/
- - Hikaru let clock run instead of resign:
- https://www.reddit.com/r/chess/comments/7vrlsb/hikaru_nakamura_lets_clock_run_out_for_more_than/
- - When Hikaru was bad for not being able to "adopt" Eric:
- https://www.reddit.com/r/chess/comments/7jlnof/anyone_know_why_nakamura_isnt_playing_chessbrah/
- --------------------------
- 4. AMAN RESPONSE SUMMARY
- --------------------------
- - Aman wakes up with two strikes in the email and gets worried.
- He clarifies that one of the strikes was a mistake.
- https://www.twitch.tv/videos/979433477?t=00h20m48s
- - They call Chessbae for clarification.
- https://www.twitch.tv/videos/979433477?t=00h22m16s
- * Summary of the conversation.
- https://clips.twitch.tv/HungryTallOstrichBrainSlug-cY7RsonEFmSZBQ-W
- - Aman says Hikaru is fun at parties. The fighting between Hikaru and Eric is unrelated and just funny.
- https://www.twitch.tv/videos/979433477?t=00h33m20s
- - Aman feels Hikaru is scared to say his true opinions, since the grow of popularity.
- He used to do funny stuff like Nakamura Knockouts, wearing a baseball hat and kicking the shit out of all the GMs.
- He looks afraid to have a controversial opinion for his vast audience.
- https://www.twitch.tv/videos/979433477?t=00h39m35s
- - Aman was disappointed for the exclusion in PogChamps.
- Some streamers seems to have favoritism in the Chessbae/Hikaru. Like a mafia ring.
- https://www.twitch.tv/videos/979433477?t=01h09m52s
- - Chessbrah invited Hikaru as a host on their channel for the event "Chessbrah invitational".
- Hikaru initially accepted the invitation, but then dropped out for ludicrous reasons.
- Hikaru told his audience that he wasn't invited to the event.
- https://www.twitch.tv/videos/979433477?t=01h14m45s
- - Someone asks Aman "Aren't you worried about chess.com backlash?"
- He respondes Hikaru should be more worried about that.
- https://www.twitch.tv/videos/979433477?t=01h16m44s
- - Aman talks about Hikaru referencing Eric-Botez controversy.
- https://www.twitch.tv/videos/979433477?t=01h17m30s
- - Somebody asks Aman to talk about Chessbae and he has nothing to say about her.
- https://www.twitch.tv/videos/979433477?t=01h24m55s
- - Aman full response (6 hours vod):
- https://www.twitch.tv/videos/979433477?t=00h19m49s
- -------------
- 5. CHESSBAE
- -------------
- - Chat logs with ChessBae94 revelant messages for 8th April Hikaru stream video: https://www.twitch.tv/videos/979861719
- # TODO: Add link to complete logs, can't post in pastebin because of 512Kb limit.
- [0:38:13] <ToysToysToys> hi @chessbae94 , kinda surprised I didn't get the boots when I said that - I haven't kept up on that drama, just felt like I'd be a horrible person
- [0:39:18] <ChessBae94> @ToysToysToys it was our mcn that struck their video - we removed it - we wanted to talk to Aman and Eric about it - they cut off communication and went the full drama route - feelsbadman. Hikaru and I are sorry it happened, hope no damage was done, hope everyone can move on
- [0:39:50] <bibbyjameschess> @ChessBae94 ya every1 needs to move on, drama isnt why were here after all :)
- [0:39:59] <ChessBae94> @bibbyjameschess I hope so
- [0:40:40] <Joe010> @ChessBae94 did you or Hikaru communicate to your MCN that you wanted or were fine with them taking it down beforehand?
- [0:41:01] <tiodae> @Joe010 Why are you bringing it up brosef?
- [0:41:29] <ChessBae94> lol @tiodae
- [0:41:34] <ToysToysToys> dmca strikes are handled by outsourced companies - sorry for bringing this up
- [0:42:23] <ChessBae94> @ToysToysToys no worries - I hope if it happens again, like it did with Anish Giri - they just dm us, we all have a laugh and fix it - no need to rake anyone over the coals
- [0:44:17] <Yourwizard666> @Chessbae94 how does it feel to be the baddest bitch in chess? The amount of eric’s dogs seething at the sight of your username must be empowering
- [0:44:40] <ChessBae94> @Yourwizard666 something about if they're not talking about you ...
- [0:44:54] <ChessBae94> @Yourwizard666 but seriously, would rather be chillin ;)
- [0:45:42] <Joe010> @Yourwizard666 you know Chessbae was once a mod on Eric's channel, but they demodded her because she's toxic, right?
- [0:45:58] <ChessBae94> @Joe010 I unmodded myself
- [0:46:11] <Joe010> @ChessBae94 that's literally not possible, liar.
- # (Note: it is possible to /unmod or /unvip)
- [0:46:17] <WanderingBishop> @Joe010 I was a mod for Chessbrah much longer than bae was and I can tell you that's not true
- [0:46:34] <ChessBae94> @Joe010 you type /unmod chessbae94 in chat of chessbrah and then you're unmodded
- [0:46:45] <Joe010> Doesn't work
- [0:46:51] <ChessBae94> it does, but that's okay
- [0:50:50] <ChicoBurger> is hikaru sad?
- [0:51:18] <y3cn3> @chicoburger people are stupid, so he is disappointed more than sad
- [0:51:32] <y3cn3> @chicoburger I think
- [0:51:32] <ChicoBurger> @y3cn3 what hapened
- [0:52:04] <y3cn3> @chicoburger check r/chess on Reddit for all the drama
- [0:52:30] <ChessBae94> @ChicoBurger it's over though - and you might catch a disease there - so good luck
- [5:13:56] <he_who_trolls> Can you forgive chess brah?
- [5:14:04] <ChessBae94> !drama @he_who_trolls
- [5:14:04] <Moobot> Bent Pixel (Multi-Channel Network) struck their video - Hikaru, chessbae and the YouTube team are sorry it happened, hope no damage was done, hope everyone can move on respectfully.
- [5:45:59] <lukeuyd> alireza wore chessbrah merch which seems weird
- [5:46:15] <ChessBae94> @lukeuyd he's a fan of the brahs - good for him - he's also a hikaru fan - also good for him
- [5:46:19] <ChessBae94> @lukeuyd no tribalism
- [5:46:58] <lukeuyd> @ChessBae94 with the context of the last week, wearing that vs hikaru seems to speak to a larger statement not just coincidence. but thats just my opinion
- [5:47:26] <ChessBae94> @lukeuyd he's a great GM - let's not pick on what his shirt was
- [5:57:31] <origins0> I'm a teacher going through some drama with a peer at work. Trust me the drama brings everyone going through it closer together
- [5:57:56] <ChessBae94> @origins0 I hope it brings the community together and I hope you make it through okay
- [5:58:48] <soochrispy_> Ben Finegold is not a good guy
- [6:00:25] <ChessBae94> @soochrispy_ let's not slam other creators here
- [6:01:06] <soochrispy_> @chessbae94 oh ok he only spent 3 hours slandering Hikaru yesterday but sure. That’s definitely a guy to defend
- [6:01:21] <ChessBae94> @soochrispy_ not defending him - just don't want to spread the negativity
- - Hikaru's 8th April stream was the last time Chessbae has chatted on Hikaru's channel
- On 9th April, some chat users were wondering where she was and they were missing her.
- On 10th April, after Hikaru statement on Chessbae, some chat users start insulting her.
- # TODO: Add full chat logs
- - Chessbae is not on Hikaru's twitch following list anymore.
- - On 10th April, Hikaru confirms Chessbae's position has changed.
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4YT8xsT9MUs
- - Twitch channels where Chessbae moderates:
- https://modlookup.3v.fi/u/chessbae94
- - (Chad) IM Lawrence Trent and Chess24 drama:
- https://www.reddit.com/r/chess/comments/mohf4n/response_from_chesscom/gu43ek4/?context=2
- - Working theories of real identity of ChessBae94:
- - A person that exchange money for power
- - Chess.com employee for make dirty business practices.
- - A rich spoiled "feminist" (that doesn't really understand what feminism is)
- - Rex Sinquefield
- - 10th April Stream relevant chat logs
- aquilaungula is a Hikaru mod
- # TODO: Add full logs
- [2:11:14] <Super__Ego> so much hate on chessbae. I dont know her but she was the one and only one lifted all chess channels years back, including chessbrah
- [2:11:35] <aquilaungula> @Super__Ego I think a lot of people are new to the Twitch world and don't know how much she did for everyone
- [2:16:17] <rollercoaster_123> @aquilaungula did chessbae get fired
- [2:16:28] <aquilaungula> @rollercoaster_123 No, she didn't
- [2:17:12] <aquilaungula> @rollercoaster_123 She's always welcome here, I think people are forgetting that Hikaru taking a more active role does not mean that Chessbae is gone from here
- [2:18:01] <engoxe> @aquilaungula Are you a chess.com mod?
- [2:18:06] <aquilaungula> @engoxe Yes I am
- [2:17:58] <kitar001> what happened with ben?
- [2:18:24] <aquilaungula> @kitar001 We had the copyright strike removed from his Youtube channel and both Karen and Ben are unbanned from here
- [2:19:23] <oddlyunspecified> @aquilaungula Do you get paid or is it just for fun?
- [2:19:48] <aquilaungula> @oddlyunspecified Yeah. I don't know if I can fully disclose how much but we do get compensated since we are technically expected to work
- [2:19:18] <quickeroats> @aquilaungula I just joined! What happened to Chessbae?? Why is she not on the followers list
- [2:20:17] <aquilaungula> @quickeroats Chessbae is still very much here and welcomed. It's just that Hikaru is now taking a more active role in producing his channel and content
- [2:27:43] <GMBenjaminFinegold> GMBenjaminFinegold subscribed at Tier 1. They've subscribed for 4 months, currently on a 1 month streak!
- [2:27:43] <Moobot> Thank you @GMBenjaminFinegold for subbing for 4 months! <3
- [2:29:02] <aquilaungula> !so @GMBenjaminFinegold
- [2:29:13] <aquilaungula> Time heals all wounds
- [2:29:21] <aquilaungula> Also, a simple talk helps too
- [2:35:44] <GMBenjaminFinegold> GMBenjaminFinegold gifted a Tier 1 sub to KarenAtlChessClub! They have given 7 Gift Subs in the channel!
- [2:35:45] <Moobot> @GMBenjaminFinegold gifted a subscription to @KarenAtlChessClub HeyGuys
- [2:35:45] <aquilaungula> Hey Karen! Glad to see you back @KarenAtlChessClub
- [2:36:03] <GMBenjaminFinegold> Go @karenatlchessclub
- - Chessbae being toxic against twitch streamer ilysuiteheart:
- https://www.reddit.com/r/chess/comments/gym7tq/chessbae_and_toxicity_confirmed/
- - Chessbae response (From chat log from twitch video #946551727)
- [0:42:15] <byugoi2> did you ever resolve that drama on reddit about you gatekeeping a female streamer chessbae
- [0:43:00] <ChessBae94> @byugoi2 that happened about 3.5 years ago - I apologized profusely within days, never did it again, and was totally wrong. That's ALL they have to paint me with and it's old drama. People make mistakes, I made one. I never did it again.
- ------------------
- 6. KARATE HIKARU
- ------------------
- - Mirrors:
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4FcokIxe50A
- https://livestreamfails.com/clip/112028
- This fighting video is very funny, but for some reason Hikaru doesn't like it. Why? Who knows.
- Maybe he only wants "safe" topics to talk about for his huge audience.
- Or maybe his big ego doesn't like it.
- - Hikaru says he knows karate and he wants to hit and kill Eric Hansen after OTB blitz match, Hansen tells GM Yasser that since Eric has actual training and weight advantage, they will have a fight with no punching allowed and Hansen will not hurt him.
- https://clips.twitch.tv/ShortCrackyVulturePogChamp-bstaMV1TKhN1Pqtc
- - GM Hess on the brawl
- https://clips.twitch.tv/FamousHelpfulShallotPeteZarollTie-Gv_gpMq_4LaMgzGD
- - Aman tells a Karate story about Hiki and GM Simon "GingerGM" Williams
- https://streamable.com/ixtxb0
- - Simon "GingerGM" Williams corrects the above story
- https://www.twitch.tv/videos/980027285?t=00h12m10s
- ---------------
- 7. NEED MORE?
- ---------------
- - Chessbrah's Eric stream that started it all (full VOD):
- https://www.twitch.tv/videos/978764250?t=00h04m53s
- - Chessbrah's Aman on drama (full VOD):
- https://www.twitch.tv/videos/979433477?t=00h06m49s
- - Hikaru 7th April VOD:
- VOD DELETED
- - GM Naroditsky and Robert Hess on Chess Drama + Bonus Stories
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1-GmVbrsjV4
- - GM Ben Finegold on drama (full VOD):
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=21mHkRNrN_Y
- - GM Hess on drama (full VOD):
- https://www.twitch.tv/videos/979656685?t=02h44m29s
- - GM Daniel Naroditsky on drama (full VOD):
- https://www.twitch.tv/videos/978891485?t=00h14m13s
- -------------------------
- 8. BONUS CLIPS (GO BEN)
- -------------------------
- - GM Ben Finegold impersonating Hikaru
- https://www.twitch.tv/gmbenjaminfinegold/clip/CrispyBeautifulSpiderKappaClaus-2rAPXb5uN7rg0ppx
- - Why GM Ben Finegold would lose a Chessboxing match with Hikaru
- https://www.twitch.tv/gmbenjaminfinegold/clip/CoweringEnthusiasticAsparagusAliens-3sRoaM9iMr0W7zdU
- - Moscow Hikaru stories
- https://www.twitch.tv/videos/979340747?t=0h43m38s
- - When Hikaru was a teenager
- https://www.twitch.tv/videos/979340747?t=0h51m10s
- - GM Magnus Carlsen is upset when a player makes Hikaru tilt /s
- https://www.reddit.com/r/chess/comments/mo447u/magnus_sarcasticsen_strikes_again/
- - Visit r/AnarchyChess for memes
- https://www.reddit.com/r/AnarchyChess/
- - IM Eric Rosen on drama
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=es-Sz8mAclg&t=783s
- ----------------
- 9. EXTRA STUFF
- ----------------
- - If you want to stay updated or discuss drama:
- https://www.reddit.com/r/HikaruNakamura
- https://www.reddit.com/r/chessbae94
- - A "Chessbae" youtube channel shows up with just one video, the Eric drunk video.
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bp34JCo5dKk
- - Chessbae seen on WagamanaTV channel. (Dota 2 streamer)
- Wagamana responds:
- https://www.reddit.com/r/DotA2/comments/mr5v8e/tyranical_supermod_chessbae94_possibly/gukqbt5/
- - Danya and Magnus just having fun, with various chess related references
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=br1ov5_Bf-8
- - Eric addressing Chessbae/Hikaru things:
- https://www.twitch.tv/videos/985682950?t=00h15m20s
- Timestamps:
- [0:22:05] Strike wern't random but premeditated
- [0:24:15] Chessbae manipulation
- [0:26:45] Alexandra Botez relationship and why Eric cut contact with Chessbae
- [0:30:50] Chessbae to Alexandra: "If you see Eric again, you will be cut off from raids, hosts and PogChamps"
- [0:39:50] Hikaru and Chessbae gaining power and manipulating the narrative
- [0:41:48] Hikaru claiming to have "suicide thoughts" while destroying Eric's life
- [0:42:25] The impact of Hikaru/Chessbae having a lot of power on Chess.com
- [0:43:44] Hikaru knew what kind of person Chessbae was
- [0:46:59] Who wouldn't bend the knee to Hikaru/Chessbae would get canceled
- [0:48:45] Imagine if Eric didn't speak out
- [0:50:20] Drama is not over
- [0:52:03] Hikaru's toxicity is not only when he loses a game. That's not really important
- Hikaru can make you lose jobs, opportunites, or gaslighting you if you don't agree with him
- [0:52:55] Eric brings up Hikaru stream response
- [0:56:20] Eric brings up Hikaru tweet
- [1:03:10] Another copyright strike from Alireza's channel, made by Chessbae
- [1:14:10] Hikaru blaming everything on Chessbae when he has responsibilities as well
- - Simultaneously, Alexandra responds to Eric comments:
- https://www.twitch.tv/videos/985744047?t=00h05m55s
- - She clarifies that they weren't in a relationship
- - She clarifies that she didn't choose "stream" over Eric
- - Chessbrah's messages during Alexandra's stream:
- [0:20:54] <chessbrah> 2970 raiders from chessbrah have joined!
- [0:22:50] <chessbrah> i wasnt trying to say that
- [0:25:35] <chessbrah> i wasnt trying to imply that, i apologize, i was meaning that i felt that at the time so i reacted badly
- [0:26:35] <chessbrah> i said i overreacted, sorry for the misinterpretation
- - Why Eric and Alexandra stopped seeing each other (snip from Eric's video)
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c72gVC6X_Yw
- - Note on Chessbrah's missed opportunities:
- - Follower chart pre chess-boom:
- https://imgur.com/rZVbseL.png
- - Follower chart post chess-boom:
- https://imgur.com/NtkTmu9.png
- - Full chart:
- https://imgur.com/9R8VryN.png
- * Hikaru tweet on drama:
- https://twitter.com/GMHikaru/status/1381615464728686594?s=19
- - Ben and Hikaru Make-up tutorial:
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lQIqex9aFgo
- * GM Daniel Naroditsky's google document response to the Chessbae/Hikaru/Chessbrah/Botezlive drama
- - This is a compilation of Daniel discord messages, compiled by some of his discord mods.
- - Daniel has approved this document, see more info at his reddit post: https://www.reddit.com/r/chess/comments/mopi1b/daniel_naroditskys_full_google_doc_response_to/gu53ejs/?context=69
- https://docs.google.com/document/d/1kyAM8d2XSN0WHyJiLqGItpuFc6G-cqmtzzbXnuTKHtU/preview
- * IM Daniel Rensch, Chief Chess Officer of Chess.com, announces updates on Chessbae's position on Chess.com
- - Quote: "[...] we have removed all Chess.com moderator and Twitch/Streamer powers from her accounts."
- https://www.reddit.com/r/chess/comments/mohf4n/response_from_chesscom/
- - A nice summary of Chessbae influence on streamers and chess.com:
- https://www.reddit.com/r/chess/comments/mo7im5/drama_hikaru_made_a_short_statement_on_stream/gu2k55a/
- - Hikaru "let's move on" message on Eric and Chessbae, during 10th April twitch stream
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4YT8xsT9MUs
- - Chessbae "Can't we just move on?" message, on Hikaru discord
- https://i.imgur.com/zswpxmo.png
- - Added new Chessbae section below with her chat logs from Hikaru streams.
- - Hikaru's mod aquilaungula confirms Chessbae is *NOT* fired and still welcome on Hikaru's channel.
- (See Section 5)
- (2021-04-12 Edit: Hikaru says he is parting ways with Chessbae)
- - Copyright strike lifted from Ben Finegold's channel.
- https://twitter.com/ben_finegold/status/1380650273924911109
- https://twitter.com/ben_finegold/status/1380671887315963904
- - /u/tryingtolearn_1234 tells a similar copyright story between St. Louis and agadmator's channels
- https://www.reddit.com/r/chess/comments/mo0ewq/strike_lifted_from_bens_channel_too_and_ben_is/gu2rged/?context=2
- ----------------
- Thanks to many reddit and twitch users for links and clips.
- Thanks to https://www.twitch.tv/Chess_Hidden_Truths
- Thanks to /u/FreudianNipSlip123
- Thanks to /u/MorugaX
- Thanks to /u/wannabe2700
- Thanks to GGxEpsilon on Youtube
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment