I wanted to chime in again and add some additional points.

In Gurp's post, he mentioned that if we were to implement the Inferno time requirement, what action would we take if the clan fills back up e.g. reducing the time.

In my opinion, the timed requirement should be a ___one___ time thing.  The standard we set for it (Inferno 85 min on-task/90 min off-task) is realistically achieveable for most of our "desireable" members.

Think about it again - who were the members that voted no to the idea?  There were 3 types of people: One who wanted alternatives, one who knew that they couldn't achieve that standard, and one who couldn't be asked to put in the effort.

I've already provided the alternatives to the members who didn't like the Inferno but considered themselves good at other PvM aspects of the game.

The Inferno timed requirement would address the massive disparity of skill gap we have at the moment.  Remember Habibi Toni? Pmy? We currently have Nieve Task filling that role now.  They're the types of people that no member wants to PvM with, and they're the types of people that our new trialists first get exposed to since everyone else already avoids them.  I was one of these people considering Habibi Toni was the first Oblivion member I raided with when I trialed and it didn't exactly give a good first impression.

Lastly, for the people that don't want to put in the effort, frankly, they deserve to get booted.  It's similar for the people that didn't want to grind the Infernal cape requirement.  Again, the bar we currently have set for the Inferno timed requirement is extremely achieveable.  I've received comments ranging from Inferno newbs to experts that ___all___ it takes is to simply not afk.  You have enough time to blood barrage to full for every wave to fulfill the timed requirement.

By having the timed requirement, it will set the standard level of our clan to an acceptable state that the entire clan would be satisfied with.  I don't want to be constantly changing my opinions back and forth but I've came to realize that this requirement should be implemented as soon as possible.  That way, the only new requirements we have to push out are EHB or gear requirements, which we can incrementally increase over time.