SVTFOE (SkyXAnon) Chapter 10: Alone (NOT LEWD!)

>The glare of the TV screen was the only thing lighting the den of the Diaz household. And there you sat, all by yourself. This wasn’t an uncommon occurrence for you. You’d been so used to being alone before you moved in here. But… that was before Star literally came crashing into your life. You never really liked anybody enough to miss them, but now, you feel like there’s a butterfly shaped hole in your soul. You miss the attention, the affection, the conversation, everything! You’d never have imagined that you’d have a crush on a young girl like this. You can’t even believe you went so far with her either. The imagery of what took place hours before still swirls in your mind. Those half lidded eyes, that hungry look on her face. The way she whispered your name. It gave you chills just to call it to mind. She knew what was going on, right? Did she leave because you went too far? The idea of it made you feel ill. You were one sick puppy. She was way younger than you, TOO YOUNG, and even if she WAS into it, you’d have a one way ticket to jail soon after.
*Sigh* God...damn it.
>You went ahead and broke out the hard stuff now that “the kids” are gone. Raphael always had a nicely stocked secret beer fridge in his man shed, and he encouraged you to grab one at your leisure; as long as you kept it full and went on beer runs, of course. And grabbed one you did. Or two, or four. As many as it takes to drown your sorrows and anxiety.
>Your eyes begin to feel heavy as you push your head deeper into the couch cushions. Damn, they still smelled like Star. Every thought of reminded you of the girl. But why did you decide to toe the line with her like that? It was a huge mistake. What the hell possessed you to do such a thing? These questions ring out in your head as you stare at the back of your eyelids; images of the night playing before you like a movie in your mind.
>You were a damn fool. You had a perfectly fine thing going with her older sister, and you’ve gone and screwed everything up because Star decided to get a little flirty with you. Now you have two Butterfly girls vying for your affection. Sky was everything Star was, but older, and more mature. She was more reserved, sorta… She was definitely different, right? Spending some time with Star brought that into question. No. That’s silly. Sky was totally different. You were sure if you needed help doing your taxes, or doing fun adult stuff like laundry, Sky would be a valuable asset. Maybe.
>Sky… you wonder where she is. What she’s up to. What her house looks like. You want to see it one day; take a tour of her childhood home… You could formally meet her parents; not lurking in the background of some weird magic mirror in Star’s room. You could go tour another dimension, hell, tour MANY dimensions. You want to see it all with her by your side. You just pray that Star won’t tell her sister how physical things have gotten between you two.
>*Tap tap tap*
>But maybe you’re over-reacting. She did just excitedly run off to go see Oskar tonight. Maybe it was just all one big misunderstanding. Yea that’s it. Man… this couch is really comfortable. You never really got the opportunity to lay on it like this, not that you’d want to do so in front of Marco and his parents. Well-
>*TAP TAP TAP TAP*
>Ow! What the hell was that?
zzhuh? fugofff...zzzz
>”Hey, Anon. Wake up sleepy head.”
>Huh? Who was that? Oh, sounds like a girl.
Star? you’re already back?
>”Nope. Guess again.”
>You abruptly throw your head up from its pillowy grave, desperate to meet her eyes.
>”Hey! You’re not allowed to peek! You can’t just cheat like that, Anon. You Cheaty Mc-cheater pants!”
SKY!
>Sky seems taken aback by your sudden burst of energy. But you couldn’t be happier to see her. There she is, the answer to all your problems. You jump up from the couch and scoop her into a hug.
>”Uhh hey anooof! Owwowwow! Ok, ok! You can put me back down now, big guy. Jeez.”
Sorry. It's just nice seeing you is all.
>”It's only been a day though...aww did you really miss me that much? That’s so adorable. You couldn’t help yourself could you Anon! So cuuutte!”
S-shutup!
>”It's ok Anon, little ol’ Sky is here now, no need to thank me. Where’s my sis? Don’t tell me she-”
Isn’t here again?
>”Aww c’mon! Uggh! You gotta be kidding me! This is like, SO typical of her. Looks like you guys were having a TOTAL blast though, I mean, look at this place.”
>Once Sky called attention to it, you finally take in the scene before you. The room was an absolute disaster. You couldn’t believe how messy it became in just a short time. Marco had left for his trip less than 12 hours ago and you’ve gone and Star’d up the whole place up in record time. Plates, knives, forks, spoons, cups, all manner of dishes and utensils were strewn around the place like confetti from a kid’s birthday party. You can’t even fathom why you and Star needed to dirty so many dishes for just two people, but you did. And damn was it filthy. If Diazes walked in right now, you would feel like a real piece of garbage for treating their house like this, and it wasn’t because the pile of literal garbage sitting next to the TV. But thankfully, they were still many hours away, and they wouldn’t be back for a little more than a full day.
>*poke* *poke*
Huh?
>”Aww man Anon, you’re a total space cadet huh? Meee too!”
>Suddenly, Sky tackles you into the couch with vigor to match your previous outburst.
OW!
>You have to hand it to these girls, they sure know how to tackle grown men like they were little toddlers. They really bring a whole new meaning to the word “manhandling”. Now you’re lying on your back on the very same couch, with a cute girl on top of you. Huge improvement from just ten minutes ago, so it's hard to complain.
>”Oh don’t be such a baby. Did you really miss me?”
Like you wouldn’t believe.
>”Wow Anon, you act like I was gone for a month or something”
Sure felt like that.
>”Heheh, don’t worry, I won’t leave anytime soon.”
>You take your hand and cup her soft chubby cheeks, inciting a confused look on Sky’s face. You slowly glide your thumb across her heart marks. They were just as soft, and warm to the touch.
God… I can’t believe how beautiful you look tonight. There’s just something about you that seems… special. There always is. You’re gorgeous.
>You can see a light blush creeping into her complexion. You witness the look on her face changing from surprise to a steadily growing lust. She moves her face closer to yours, not knowing she was going to continue what you and her sister had started just a couple hours before.
>”ah...Anon I-”
>You quiet her with a touch of your fingertips to her lips. The gesture makes her swoon even harder. Her face is so red and flustered, but her eyes betray her embarrassment. You could see them swimming with want. Filled to the brim with desire.
Sky…
>Here you were again with a Butterfly girl straddling you on the living room couch. It made you feel odd, it was too similar to earlier on. You can’t help but think back to Star. That tension you felt between you and her. Pushing your hard- NO! What the hell are you doing? You’ve got the solution to this mess literally lying on top of you trying to kiss you! This was it, you weren’t going to hold back. If you kissed Sky here and now, you were going to take it all the way. You needed it, to get Star off your mind, to put that whole ordeal behind you.
>*rrnrnnngggnrgarrarrarrarararar*
Uhhh…
>”hahaha oops! I uh… I guess I was so busy before that I forgot to eat. Sorry, stomach’s got a mind of her own. Heheh.”
Oh. I was wondering what that noise was.
>Sky puts her hand behind her head, scratching her scalp as her face glows from embarrassment, her eyes refusing to meet yours.
>”So uhhm… got any food?”
Actually, as a matter of fact, I do.


>It was only a bit of time before you had the leftovers from lunch plated before you and Sky. You were happy that this stuff wasn’t gonna go to waste, considering that Star was away on her trip at Oskar’s Mom’s lake house or whatever. Sky seemed to be thrilled about the food. A little too thrilled, to be completely honest.
>”Wow Anon! Did you really make all this?”
Well, uhh, I mean, I put it together is all.
>”Aww c’mon Anon, you don’t have to be bashful about it. It looks great! You really shouldn’t be so hard on yourself.”
Oh c’mon, it's nothing!
>”Nuh-uh, you don’t get to downplay this, bucko. You did a really, really good job Anon. Star was telling me that Marco usually does the cooking. Does she know about this? Huh? Huh? Are you holding out on her nonny boy?”
>Sky gives your arm a playful punch and a wink before she drags you over to the table to eat.
Yea, I mean, I’ve cooked for her before. But, for the most part, I’m sorta lazy when it comes down to it. Plus Marco’s parents make some seriously good food. It's hard to compete with that.
>”Really? With skills like this, I’m surprised I don’t have to fight her off of you. Hehe! You know what they say, the quickest way to a woman’s heart is through her belly.”
W-what?
>What the hell? Deja Vu seems to be hitting you like a brick wall. No no, that’s fine. It was just a coincidence. Star and Sky probably both heard that little bit of knowledge from their father. And considering what you’ve heard about River’s proclivity for meat, it actually makes sense… At least you hope it does.
>”Is there something wrong? C’mon Anon, sit down already. Lets eat so we can haaang out! Oh man! These jalapeno poppers are awesome! I should have had more-uhhh I mean-I should have more haha! They’re spicy! Just how I like it! Haahaaaaa!”
>You finally make your way over to your seat across from your Butterfly companion, but something about this situation makes you feel uneasy. You can’t exactly put your finger on why.
Are you...sweating?
>”Hahaaa me?! Uhh… of course! These areeee... really hot! Phew.”
>You stare at her in confusion. Something feels different about Sky, but you’re having a hard time telling what. Hmm, same headband, same blue stripe, same earrings, no, nothing seems off physically. So what is it? You try to remember if she acted differently last time, but your memories of Star and Sky seem to meld together. Damn, they weren’t kidding about being very similar.
>”Anonnn! You’re staring at me again. I’m not on the menu...unless you want me to be. Heeh heeh hehhh!”
>Jesus, this girl was too much. The way she ate her food was the exact opposite of erotic, but nonetheless it makes you want to pin her to the wall anyway.
Maybe for dessert?
>”Woo! Wow, is it getting hot in here or is it these things? *crunch* Mmmm, so gooey and cheesey. Uhhhhuhuhuhhh soooo gooood. If you promised to make me these when I wanted them, I’m pretty sure I’d marry you on the spot, Anon. Among other things I’d do. Hehheheeee.”
Wow, you’re extra flirty tonight aren’t you?
>”Hmm, you don’t say? Welp! That was good! That’s enough food for now, let's go hang out on the couch!”
B-but! Wait! I didn’t even eat yet!
>”Aww cmmonnn! We gotta make up for lost time Anon. Here, bring it over to the TV. There we go, little bit of this, ooo, that looks good, some of that. Aaaandd! Here ya go! One dinner plate to go! Now let's get moving!
>You just stand there in awe. Something about this isn’t sitting right with you. Maybe it was the four beers you chugged earlier but… Something is VERY OFF about this. Were you dreaming? Was this another one of those dreams? You WERE just thinking about Sky right before you fell asleep. Maybe that’s why this feels so surreal.
 >“Hey! Get your butt over here Anon!”
>Nope, can’t shake that feeling. Man, this dinner was weird. Every moment seemed to remind you of the lunch from earlier. There’s something about Sky that’s making you feel uncomfortable, but what was it? At first, you felt like Star and Sky were different. When you first met Sky it truly seemed that way, but now it seems like they were clones. As if they were the same per-
AHHHHHHHHHH! What the hell!
>”Whats with all your inner monologue crap! Stop pondering out into the distance and lets have some fun! Here, let me take your plate annnnnnnnnd”
Put me down Sky! WHOA!
>”ALL ABOARD THE SKY EXPRESS! DESTINATION: DIAZ FAMILY COUCH! KEEP YOUR ARMS AND LEGS INSIDE THE CABIN AT ALL TIMES! PLEASE REMEMBER TO THROW OUT ALL GARBAGE IN THE RECEPTACLES PROVIDED ON THE STATION PLATFORM.”
>Manhandling. A Butterfly family tradition. You end up unceremoniously dumped back on the couch, face down in the cushions that still smelled like Star. Wait a minute. Was that how Sky smelled too?
Man! Between You, Star, and I, we’re going to break this damn couch in half. Is there some sort of family rule where you have to tackle your friends into things at high speed?
>”Wait… Star tackled you into the couch too? Were you ROUGHHOUSING with my little sister?!”
I uhh! I didn’t uhhm! I mean…
>”Ahahah! I’m just messing with ya Anon. Look!”
>Sky produces a jewel case from behind her, practically shoving it in your face for emphasis.
>”You didn’t tell me Star brought her Pony Gamestation! Are you nuts!? We coulda been playing it this whole time! She’s even got Lederhosen Tycoon 2: Mob War! YOU’RE HOLDING OUT ON ME DUDE! C’mon, scoot down to the floor and bring those pillows with you. Let's make a fort and start a file together!”
>Aww, she wanted to play video games with you in a pillow fort? That was the cutest thing you can think of. What were you even saying before? Sky is totally different than Star. Duh! Star never asked to make a pillow fort with you… well, not that you ever had the opportunity to. But what if Star never had a chance!? Not that it would matter, she’s younger than you. It’d be weird to make a pillow fort and play video games with her!
Waw-HEY!
>*THUNK!* You find yourself on the ground again, but this time, at least you’re on your back.
Goddamn it Sky! Whats with you butterfly girls and physically fo-
>Sky’s lips unexpectedly meet yours. You can feel your brain start slowing to a crawl. A wave of calmness rushes over you as you feel Sky’s hand gently trail your jaw. You let out a breath of air that expels all the anxiety and nervous energy pent up inside of you.
>”Anon? Does anybody ever tell you that you think too much? Now c’mon, stop spacing out and let's play already!”