Advertisement
Guest User

Untitled

a guest
Oct 23rd, 2017
66
0
Never
Not a member of Pastebin yet? Sign Up, it unlocks many cool features!
text 12.44 KB | None | 0 0
  1. 83.795835/8640 #VALUE! Economic "benefits"
  2. 128.662821 00:02:09 our employees live in burnaby and have houses, shop, pay taxes, etc
  3. 202.222806 00:03:22 if you go onto our website...they'll tell you ever single line item, all the financials
  4. 248.768587 00:04:09 we train emergency response personnel in each community
  5. 520.939571 00:08:41 safety is our number one concern
  6. 700.475866 00:11:40 [Regarding the Burnaby Fire Department's 2015 tactical risk analysis]
  7. 814.109878 00:13:34 number one cause of that in the world [rim seal fire] is lightning, so we're in a low lightning place
  8. 877.261335 00:14:37 if there is going to be any fires it would start out as a rim fire
  9. 881.218494 00:14:41 so then the rim seal could sink a roof and you could get a catastrophic full surface fire
  10. 922.449691 00:15:22 if this intersection is closed..../and that's for anything...
  11. 939.530227 00:15:40 the city of burnaby probably has plans in place
  12. 1024.275781 00:17:04 "we have three emergency response techs..."" ""...about 20 operators
  13. 1067.4639721067.463972""so you're saying that the fire department is mistaken?/""because they don't know what it takes for us to implement our..."
  14. 1188.931959 00:19:49 why not put fewer tanks
  15. 1267.672224 00:21:08 everybody's, they can have their own opinion, I guess
  16. 1412.293188 00:23:32 I'm sure the city has plans for evacuation
  17. 1442.381985 00:24:02 "what they don't have is the capacity to put out a tank fire/...we recognize that...
  18. 1697.0695221697.069522""we meet with the city monthly"
  19. 1701.587878 00:28:22 I don't understand how you could possibly have 26 tanks in this geographical area/because we do
  20. 1803.111185 00:30:03 so you're saying that if you have a tank on fire there, there will be no fire going to the trees/correct
  21. 1926.786188 00:32:07 "so you will do it regardless of whether or not the city is satisfied?/yes
  22. 1941.5116151941.511615""we're very convinced..."
  23. 1947.78551 00:32:28 we wouldn't do it otherwise
  24. 1978.579401 00:32:59 there isn't a facility, around that is going to be as safe as this one
  25. 2011.675638 00:33:32 [shellmont farm has 7 tanks]/What does that matter?
  26. 2219.606346 00:37:00 so you trust the city?
  27. 2239.22426 00:37:19 i wouldn't work for a company I didn't believe in
  28. 2291.823295 00:38:12 "I'm not going through this report with you...because it is from 2015...
  29. 2346.9165382346.916538""but the whole mountain is connected right.../yep, but its better than being in the street"
  30. 2356.615175 00:39:17 because the residents asked us to build a tunnel, its $110 million
  31. 2371.892206 00:39:32 why not just not do the project/cause that's not an issue, we have the approval to do it
  32. 2380.286179 00:39:40 because there is a market for it, and we believ...and there's is a use for it
  33. 2440.171182 00:40:40
  34. 2440.171182 00:40:40 I'm not saying we should stop using oil, I'm saying this is incredibly dangerous
  35. 2485.231829 00:41:25 wouldn't it be better if we use our own product rather than importing...
  36. 2502.315364 00:41:42 maybe in 20 years time there won't be oil in those tanks, we'll be storing water, we're just a moving company
  37. 2617.240848 00:43:37 I do it because i do it for future generations
  38. 2632.892011 00:43:53 "trans mountain is a legal fiction/I disagreee/its a legal fiction/its not...
  39. 2729.0485712729.048571""...nobody trusts the national energy board..."
  40. 2891.69408 00:48:12 "primary interest is in profit
  41. 3012.7773013012.777301""reclamation activities will be scheduled to adhere to the"
  42. 3156.475221 00:52:36 there's all this hedging/I know
  43. 3275.526144 00:54:36 "they live in the community...does Ian Anderson live in the community?/no...
  44. 3277.4266883277.426688
  45. 3305.4023683305.402368""they depend on their employees to tell them whether its dangerous or not"
  46. 3459.962197 00:57:40 federal law is number one, provincial law is number two and municipal law is number 3
  47. 3491.927381 00:58:12 they're pretty strict on following the law
  48. 3513.99936 00:58:34 but if you also are aware of the standards an oil company is held to vs a forestry company
  49. 3572.528469 00:59:33 you know somebody walking on a trail and throwing a cigarette can put a fire on the mountain
  50. 3604.108629 01:00:04 I know there hasn't been a lot of discussion with the city of burnaby...
  51. 3682.735445 01:01:23 no talking
  52. 3722.242731 01:02:02 talking
  53. 3731.756373 01:02:12 "transmountain will meet or exceed expectations outlined...where prac
  54. 3754.9909333754.990933""the national energy board act permits you to basically do anything, if you read the act/ ok, that's one way of looking at it"
  55. 3797.330603 01:03:17 if we need to get a permit we will get it but if its not necessary
  56. 3804.550485 01:03:25 what to you think the purpose of municipal permits is/there's a lot of permits...there's safety...
  57. 3883.395755 01:04:43 no talking
  58. 4028.880213 01:07:09 we are living in a seismic zone, yes
  59. 4033.08544 01:07:13 what if drilling causes an earthquake?/I haven't heard that one before
  60. 4050.709163 01:07:31 do you know where the fault lines are?/I don't personally know
  61. 4081.889963 01:08:02 does somebody know what will happen if there's an earthquake"/we have mitigation plans, we can't overlook that option given where we live
  62. 4110.133931 01:08:30 "and we're not saying that nobody knows...
  63. 4125.0106034125.010603""somebody does know"
  64. 4128.615083 01:08:49 there's a lot at risk here/abosolutely, there are a lot of people in that area
  65. 4188.296533 01:09:48 if there's a fire at the tank farm the whole mountain would burn/absolutely
  66. 4298.902869 01:11:39 I know how much violence they're willing to use/and we...we're doing everything in our power so it doesn't come to that, but at the end of the day...
  67. 4345.531051 01:12:26 "but you know that violence and force will be used.../we can't comment on that either
  68. 4401.7718614401.771861no talking
  69. 4532.1912324532.191232[from 2015 BFD tactical risk analysis] "" the average tank distance to fenceline in tank diameters is reduced by 61%/I'm not sure where they got that number "
  70. 4553.244672 01:15:53 what's the average distance between the tanks?/don't have the exact numbers on me at this time, but we meet the standards and the codes for nfpa 24 and nfpa 11 we also meet the csa standards for the tank berms
  71. 4694.125227 01:18:14 there's less room for firefighters to deploy if there's failure/oh no, no its designed so the firefighters can get in there with all the fire trucks and fire equipment
  72. 4786.741248 01:19:47 but you wouldn't be doing it if it weren't for money/its always, of course its always about money.../why not just not do it/its part of bussiness/...there are 30,000 people who could get trapped on a burning mountain
  73. 4804.749995 01:20:05 is kinder morgan gonna pay for funerals if there's a catastrophic failure/there's insurance coverage
  74. 4891.394048 01:21:31 so there'd be fire, there'd be smoke, we would make an effort to put it out
  75. 4910.536021 01:21:51 probable at all means there's 30,000 people stuck on the mountain with no where to go
  76. 4918.31296 01:21:58 well why would you say there's no where to go?
  77. 4932.102827 01:22:12 senior existing vp...??
  78. 4951.57248 01:22:32 part of the risk assesment looks at the heat from a full surface fire...the university wouldn't be affected by that
  79. 4966.443691 01:22:46 that's the city's report and the city's report doesn't talk about potential consequences...it doesn't talk about probabilities or potential consequences/it does talk about it...
  80. 4981.544277 01:23:02 "the city has their study
  81. 4990.4134834990.413483""my question is who is responsible if there's a catastrophic failure to the families who will lose their children,I don't know how else to put it/that's a very inflammatory sort of question/well it is, its meant to be
  82. 5013.5913815013.591381there's civil liability, um, there's all the court process, we have insurance...how the world works...just like if you drive a car and you run into somebody you're responsible for having done it, its the same for us operating a pipeline for having done it, that's how it works
  83. 5032.4220595032.422059we're responsible for all the things we're legally responsible for
  84. 5058.9422935058.942293""there's risks involved in all human endeavors "
  85. 5093.021013 01:24:53 the province has actually approved the project.../which government was that?/the provincial government/which/well there's only one provincial government
  86. 5102.611115 01:25:03 was it the liberal government or the ndp government?/so as you know it was when...the liberal party was the majority of government"
  87. 5117.968384 01:25:18 "the current provincial government has not approved the project i take it/well they haven't revoked the approvals...
  88. 5155.5368965155.536896You're the VP of Operations
  89. 5166.6561715166.656171""part of my job is to make sure that its not a massive risk to public safety "
  90. 5197.941419 01:26:38 \
  91. 5197.941419 01:26:38 you asked me about liability.../you obviously assumed it was economic liability, I'm asking whose socially or morally responsible/you know what i know we won't come to any agreement...
  92. 5232.241323 01:27:12 no talking
  93. 5287.531861 01:28:08 "how will you get 400 tankers a year through second narrows for example and through the harbour while all the other traffic is happening/well its like air traffic control...
  94. 5324.4887045324.488704could be up to 34 [tankers a month], could be
  95. 5346.0882775346.088277""there was a dock master at one of the hearings he said 'I don't see how this is physically possible'/but it is physically possible, in actual fact our contribution is 14%..."
  96. 5427.008853 01:30:27 ...and then someone is piloting the tanker/correct/but what if the pilot is drunk/the pilot won't be drunk
  97. 5433.786368 01:30:34 Exxon Valdez the pilot was drunk/but that was however many years ago a lot of lessons have be learned from that
  98. 5470.268075 01:31:10 what if there's a situation like with the deepwater horizon where kinder morgan simply chooses not to maintain its vessels/but they aren't our vessels actually
  99. 5512.811861 01:31:53 I keep getting back to human error or human failure or human negligence/I think you have to have more faith
  100. 5546.945195 01:32:27 we're not going to talk about that report any more we've talked an enormous amount about that report
  101. 5634.075307 01:33:54 no talking
  102. 5801.713664 01:36:42
  103. 5855.248043 01:37:35 [informing the community about 2009 spill]...it was done it just wasn't done as timely as we should have
  104. 5862.958421 01:37:43 how much capital is available for emergency response?/if there's an incident, we do what we need to...
  105. 5967.773696 01:39:28 so industry has to learn, as to do the neighbors have to learn actually, how to coexist together
  106. 6033.73568 01:40:34 "So I'm just think of climate change, so scientists are saying that for example the tar sands are not compatible with dealing with climate change in a serious manner/some are some aren't, there's a debatable opinion...
  107. 6172.1204056172.120405""no one's debating climate chnage but i think what we're putting forward here is canadian development.../but why.../ because we do this well and we do this responibly/but that doesn't mean it should be done
  108. 6207.9030616207.903061""but this is all assuming we should be doing this in the first place/ok but the fact is that we do it and we do it well and we're accountable for it... "
  109. 6225.286485 01:43:45 being good at doing a bad plan isn't good/but its doing something very well
  110. 6265.618432 01:44:26 "no other pipeline's ever had to buy 30 million dollars worth of carbon offsets/so you're just paying your way out/but we're growing the clean tech ability in doing that/with tar sands?/that's what an offset is right?...where would 30 million dollars come from
  111. 6289.8667526289.866752but its not a lot of money for transmountain/it is a lot of money
  112. 6299.6916916299.691691so you're taking 30 million dollars from 7 billion dollars/30 million dollars that wasn't there when we first got through the approval stage, it is a lot of money, its a lot of money
  113. 6324.5298356324.529835""imagine going to your shareholders and your funders...and everyone'd be like 'well that's not pipeline bussiness' well it is now in canada for the first time ever
  114. 6336.3549876336.354987""the pipeline's gonna go ahead and we might launch a new technology that would take away the need for oil down the road"
  115. 6345.654272 01:45:46 we can make things without oil, we're not going to die if we don't have oil/where's the money come from? how can we invest without the money/well you seem to have 7 billion dollars/because its predicated on delivering oil in a pipeline at the end of project
  116. 6499.023438 01:48:19 [remainder a discussion on police violence]
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment
Advertisement