Imperfect Star Perfect Jackie

Star leaned back, as she sat on Marco's bed, and watched him get ready for his valentine's date with Jackie Lynn Thomas. He was in the middle of fiddling with his black stone cuff links, doing his best to squeeze the metal through the cuffs of his crisp white shirt. Eventually, after getting his first cuff linked, Marco took a break. "You're going to be okay on your own? I mean, it's not like me and Jackie can't spend time with y-" Star shot forward, as she hastily interrupted him. "Marco, I'll be fine. Valen-mine's day isn't even a thing on Mewni."
"Well, if you're sure." Marco said. Awkwardly fiddling with his free cuff link. After silence fell, Star stood up and walked over to Marco. Before using her dainty long fingers to help put the cuff into place. When Star finished, she looked up at Marco and realised that she wanted to button up his collar and do up his red tie. But Marco had already care of all of that. So there was nothing left for Star to do. Expect awkwardly stare at Marco. "Is there something on my face?" He asked, only able to see Star's gaze as platonic.
"Just a cute little mole." Star brought up, in a voice as energised as she could manage, as she pointed at Marco's beauty spot. Marco gave a soft-hearted chuckle. "You've always liked my mole."
"Mhm." Star forced through pursed lips. Before backing off. Marco put his hands behind his back to stop himself from fidgeting.
"Well, there's nothing left to do except wait for Jackie." He confirmed. As his fidgeting habit turned towards him balancing on his tippy toes. "For you maybe. This princess has her own plans." Star snapped her fingers and her wand appeared out of thin air. Hovering in front of her near arm's length. Grabbing it, she twirled it around and, after a flash of bright light, her casual clothes became mock wizard's robes. Her outfit complete with a golden beard. "Tabletop games with Alfonso?" Marco guessed. Star cringed at the idea.
"I'm going to be practising my magic." She told him. After removing the beard, she expanded on what she had in mind. "If I have to be queen, someday, then I'm committing to the idea that I'll do things my way. With my own spells."
"Wow. I'm glad you've got your-" Marco was interrupted by the sound of a doorbell.  Star silently motioned for Marco to answer the door and he hurried off. Taking his black suit jacket off of the door and slipping his arms through the sleeves as he hurried downstairs. Star slowly following after him.


When Marco opened the door, he smiled brightly upon seeing Jackie. Once again, she was wearing a nautical themed dress. This time, the colours were reminiscent of the sea at sunset with much warmer colours fitting of valentine's day. "You look beautiful, Jackie." He told her, as he took a step forward and stretched out his hands. Jackie placed hers in his and reciprocated his compliment. "Thanks, Marco. You look more handsome when you're dressed so smart." Star arrived just in time to see Marco and Jackie give each other a peck on the lips. It was a gut-wrenching experience. But she didn't want to get between Marco and Jackie, so she acted as if it didn't mean anything to her. As if it never could mean anything to her. "Hey Jackie!" She cried out, still wearing her robes, as she floated towards the couple on a low flying cloud. "Oh, hey Star." Jackie called back, upon noticing star, not letting go of Marco's hands. "Nice cloud." Jackie's compliment weighed down on Star. Jackie was cool about everything. Meanwhile Star was doing parlour tricks to act cool. "Can I expect to see Marco home before midnight?" Star teased, expecting Marco to awkwardly flail and protest the implication. "Maybe. But my parents aren't going to be home tonight. So, we'll see how it goes." Marco and Star blushed bright red. Jackie went there and put it out that, if Marco played his cards right, they'd be having sex. Star didn't know what to say and instead played ignorant. "Okay, you two have fun now." She almost demanded as her posture shifted to suggest that it was time for Marco and Jackie to be moving on. "Alright. I hope you have a cool date too, Star." Jackie said, as she stepped aside to let Marco out of the house.
"Bye Star, remember to take care of the laser puppies." Marco called out into the quiet house, as he left with Jackie. Star didn't reply. Completely mute as she watched Marco leave with Jackie. Eventually, she angrily slashed with her wand and the front door slammed shut.


Marco and Jackie walked down the sidewalk, with the setting sun on their back. Hand in hand as they travelled in bliss. "Can we discuss how I'm going to pay for the restaurant bill?" Marco asked all of a sudden. Causing Jackie to laugh at him. "Don't we usually do this at the restaurant?" She fired back.
"We do. But I thought rather than do that in a restaurant, in front of everybody, we could agree that I'm going to pay the bill here." Marco answered.
"You say that. But we always end up splitting the bill anyway."
"Yeah and this time I want to do something nice, you know, because you're so nice." Marco stood his ground. But Jackie took a different approach. "You don't have to try and impress me, Marco." She told him. Adding. "I already like you. So, I don't need any grand gestures. I just want you." Marco smiled. Being told that he didn't have to impress Jackie warmed his heart. "Then what about pulling up chairs? Last time, you pulled up a chair for me, before you sat down, and everyone was giving me weird looks. So, I think, this time, I should definitely be the one to pull up a chair for you." Jackie wore a warm smile on her face as her boyfriend went through a list of petty tribulations. "They're just jealous. I bet all the guys would like if their girlfriend did little things for them." Like this, the two continued. With Marco anxieties getting the better of him and Jackie gently petting him verbally. Soothing his worries.


Meanwhile, Star, having returned to her casual clothes, was preparing her newest spell. She was venturing into unknown territory. A dark spell of her very own. Stand her feet shoulder-width apart. She breathed in and began a slow chant. When she finished, purple fire consumed her and she appeared at a restaurant. She exhaled, from relief, upon realising that her spell had worked and then looked around. Star hadn't lied. She had wanted to practice magic. Right now she was using an improved version of the all seeing eye. A version that would like her view who she was spying on from the shadows. It just so happened that practising magic had co-incided with spying on Marco. That's the excuse she wanted to give. Star wanted to be caught. To be forced to justify her actions. But there was no chance of that happening. Once she spotted Marco and Jackie. She marched over to them and they didn't see or hear her. But she could see and hear everything. "Hello, welcome to Jonathan's. It's half price for couples on valentine's day." The old woman at the service counter announced.
"I know, that's why we came today." Marco admitted. Causing the old woman to roll her eyes. "Marco Diaz and Jackie Lynn Thomas. We have a reservation for table two." Jackie declared. Trying to steer the attention away from Marco's thrifty habits. "Of course, feel free to take a seat and a waiter will be with you shortly." The woman pointed in a vague direction and let the teens get on with it. Leaving Marco and Jackie to look for their table. Star following close behind.


When they found their table, Jackie, as she had made clear she would, pulled out a seat for Marco. Before taking her own. Star scoffed at this. She felt that, whereas Jackie forced Marco to let her do that, she would use her magic to do everything for the both of them. Star even stepped up her game and thought about how she could take the date to the skies. They didn't even need to go to a restaurant. They could have a picnic on a cloud. But they weren't having a picnic on a cloud. Star was watching Marco having dinner with Jackie at a restaurant. When this realisation sunk in. Star quickly grew bored and bitter. She was ultimately watching a couple choose their meals from a menu. Before waiting for a waiter to take their order. Reason told her that she had seen enough and that this act of spying wasn't going anywhere.


Eventually Star relented and called off the spell. Finding herself in her room, as if she had never left. She stood very still for a moment. Keen to go back. In case she might miss something. Perhaps she could spot Jackie do something that Star could use against her. She had to slip up at some point and, when she did, Star Butterfly would be there to see it. But Star knew that Jackie was nicer than that. She didn't have secrets. She didn't spy on people. She didn't hope to manipulate people. That was all Star. In a fit of frustration, Star flung herself onto her bed. Burying her face into the duvet covers.


For an hour, she stayed there. Trying to fall asleep. But her mind didn't give up. Her new dark spell kept calling to her. Unsurprisingly, Star's will broke down and she begrudgingly returned to the act of spying. With a heavy heart, she sighed and committed to the spell. After the purple flames engulfed her. She heard the sound of keys jingling, followed by muffled laughter. Star opened her eyes and blood drained from her face. She was being confronted with the biggest piece of evidence that there was no longer any room in Marco's heart for Star. A click signalled a door being unlocked and then Star watched Jackie let Marco into Jackie's home. Star followed them through, before Jackie closed the door behind her. She didn't know why she hadn't fled. Called off the spell and escaped back to Mewni. Where her heart hurt less. But something kept her in Jackie house. Watching them both. "Here we are Marco." Jackie sang, before biting her lip.
"Well, we still have one staircase to climb. Unless, you want to do it here. In the living room." Star had never heard Marco suggest sex. She didn't know that he thought about it. Everything about him had seemed so chaste. So pure. He had been like a fairytale. But now. "Maybe next time?" Jackie playfully suggested. "But, for now, I want to do this in a comfy bed."
"Okay, let's upstair go for se-"Marco coughed. He was so nervous that he was tripping over himself and was unable to say the word sex. Star found this so endearing that she couldn't help but show it on her face. The same was true of Jackie. "Come on, Marco. Let's go upstairs." Jackie suggested, as she took the lead.


Jackie let Marco into her room, completely ignorant of the fact that Star was following them, and Marco took the time to look around the room for the first time. Looking at all the memorabilia of a sporty girl that had grown up into a young woman. A ruffling sound distracted Marco and he turned to see Jackie letting her dress fall to the floor. Before stepping out of the crumpled heap. Marco was frozen. Jackie confidently stood in only a white bra and panties. "So, what do you think?" She asked, with her hands behind her back, as she leaned forward. "I think I better get undressed." Marco answered slowly. Fiddling with his jacket, he took it off and quickly scanned the room for somewhere to put it. Jackie smiled and casually pointed at a wardrobe. Marco paced over to the piece of furniture in a hurry and open the doors, hanging his jacket on one of them. Before he was caught by Jackie. Who hugged him from behind. "Hey, know that, whatever happens, I love you, okay Marco?" Jackie whispered. Barely loud enough for Marco to hear. But he still heard Jackie's soft voice over the sound of Star's heart being torn in two. "I love you two, Jackie. I didn't always think about us like this. But I did always think about us." Marco confessed without anything holding him back. Unable to hear Star's heart being torn into four pieces. He slowly began to unbutton his shirt. "Uh, Jackie? You kinda need to let go of me, so I can take my shirt off."
"Oh, okay." Jackie backed off in a rare moment of awkward fumbling for her. Marco turned to face her and started to fiddle with his cuff links. "Here, let me get those for you." She said, reaching over for the black stone around one cuff. "Star got them for me for our date. Even helped me put them on." Marco explained.
"Star's a good friend." Jackie said with a sweet smile. "And, you know, I'll have to thank her sometime."
"Why's that?" Marco inquired.
"Because now I get to help take these cuff links off." Jackie answered. Her voice a little sensual.


The near naked couple were now standing in only their underwear. Star watching a view of Marco that she had once taken for granted. This is the first time that she had seen Jackie showing off so much skin. But this sight wasn't meant for her. She wasn't supposed to see Jackie's C cup size breasts or the supple flesh that adorned Jackie's skater thighs. Those were meant for Marco. Jackie took a step forward and pressed her chest against Marco's. Allowing Marco to put his hands on Jackie's slim waist and lean in for a kiss. Star also had a slim waist. One she was quite proud of. But, looking at Jackie's flaring hips, she realised how little that meant without the right figure to show it off. Marco and Jackie's lips met and Star inhaled sharply. A painful lump in hear throat appeared as she watched it all playout. As the kiss became more passionate. Marco lifted one hand, trailing a finger up Jackie's spine, making Star desperately wish that this was happening to her, before he eventually reached Jackie's hair. Marco sank his hand into her soft hair, as he drew as close as he could. The gentle kiss becoming a make-out session. Jackie's hair bobbed slightly and Star realised that her hair, though spun like gold, wasn't what Marco wanted.


All of a sudden, Jackie broke the kiss. "Is something wrong?" Marco asked.
"No. I just think it's time to move on." Jackie told him as she unhooked her bra. Letting it fall to the floor. But she wasn't done yet and she pulled her panties down. Showing Star how much her derrière couldn't match up to Jackie's. When Jackie straightened up. She put her hands on her hips and looked down at Marco's boxer shorts. Marco got the idea and took them off. But Jackie didn't stop looking. Instead now spying a view of Marco's erect penis. "That's going to be inside of me." She announced in an almost matter-of-fact way. Star read it as, never going to be inside of her. But Jackie couldn't have known that. Instead, she walked forward and pushed Marco down, against the bed, with one gentle hand. "I'm already really excited." Jackie admitted and, as Marco looked at Jackie, he could tell. She was, despite her confident attitude, bright red and her pussy was getting soaked. Jackie hopped up onto bed and put her hands onto Marco's shoulders. Marco, in turn, using his hands to support Jackie's lower back. "Geronimo, Diaz!" Jackie yelled out and dropped herself onto Marco's cock. Yelping, after her hymen broke. "Oh, my god, Jackie! Are you okay, do we need to-" Jackie interrupted Marco's panic by pressing a single finger to his lips. She then brought hers to his and started to slowly bounce up and down as she held the hot kiss for a solid minute.


When they broke, Jackie couldn't help but moan as they sped up. "This is starting to feel good. Marco." Jackie panted between soft moans.
"Jackie, this already feels really good for me." Marco grunted. His voice barely audible above the sound of flesh slapping and wood creaking. Jackie continued moaning in rhythm as her big butt bounced in the air. Marco wanted to get a good feel of Jackie's jiggling rear. But was afraid to move his hands. So, he instead settled for planting kisses on Jackie's neck. Which made her squeal with delight. "That's so good! Keep doing that!" Jackie yelled and moaned after Marco gave her a hickie. Jackie drew up close, throwing her arms around Marco's neck and pulling him to her chest. Slowing down to enjoy every inch of her cock as she switched to more powerful thrusts. Marco used to opportunity to kiss Jackie's breasts. Causing Jackie to giggle. "I bet you love them." Jackie panted in a husky voice. She began to speed up and pushed her weight down on Diaz. Causing him to lie flat against the bed as Jackie rode his cock. "I think this it, Marco!" Jackie exclaimed. Her excitement palpable as she neared towards orgasm. "Jackie, I'm going to cum." Marco moaned doing his best to hold on.
"Me to! I'm getting really close!" Jackie cried out. Tears in her eyes. Then Marco grunted and white hot sperm was shot into Jackie. Jackie moaned as she felt it. But she needed just a few more seconds and continued to ride Marco's ejaculating dick until she finally came. Jackie screamed when she did and moaned loudly until she finally petered out into loud, forceful panting. Her chest heaving and her tongue lolled out. Her hair clung to her back, as her hand clung to Marco's shoulders.


Then, she collapsed on top of him. Knocking the wind out of Marco. "Sorry. Marco. I. I didn't mean that." Jackie managed an apology between pants. Before rolling over and laying next to Marco. His semen dripping out of her. "That was... I want to say wow. But mindblowing feels closer."
"Yeah, I-I-Ihm" Marco mumbled a reply that never came. Causing Jackie to laugh.
"That feels close to what I wanted to say." Jackie told her lover as she put her hand in his. The two rested for a while. Their eyes closed as the enjoyed the warmth of being near each other and the blissful sensation of having climaxed together.
"You know, we've got to get up eventually. We can't sleep like this." Marco pointed out.
"That sounds like future Marco and Jackie problems." Jackie reassured him.
"I'm serious, Jackie." Marco argued. Getting a simple response in return.
"In a bit." Marco gave in and tightly gripped Jackie's hand. Ignoring the growing pain in his back. From the shadows, Star Butterfly was silently crying. She had yelled, paced and pulled her hair and now she was all-tired out. Completely defeated. Trying to grasp one last minuscule piece of warmth. She reached out for Marco's free hand and tried to hold it. But her hand slipped through his. Her spell was imperfect.