Name/Genre

Where to DL
Torrents
http://www.nyaa.eu/   <---Best for anime torrents
http://kat.ph/
http://thepiratebay.se/
Or search on Sub groups site.

Stream?
http://watchanimeon.com/
netflix

***Must Watch(See descriptions below)*** [recommended Sub group in brackets]
[steins; subs]Steins; Gate 
[mazui]Katanagatari
School Days
Seto no Hanayome
Tengan toppa gurren lagann (avail on netflix dubbed, ew)
(Maybe) Puella Madoka Magica - gotta get passed the cutesy sailor moon style but this was interesting show


*****The Best of the best 5 star******
Angel Beats (Comedy/Drama)
Code Geass & Code Geass R2
Cowboy Bebop (Space Cowboy Action) - A classic of anime and an amazing Dub/English voice job.
Death Note
Eureka Seven (Mecha/Romance) - Surfing robots cool action and a cute love story.
FLCL (? crazy but cool)- A classic of anime viewable on netflix.
Hajime 1 & 2
Katanagatari (Action/Romance?) - Awesome art/action/plot with nice love story as undertone.
Minami-ke (Comedy/Slice of life) - Three sisters living on their own shows about daily life its pretty funny.
Nodame Cantabile (3 seasons) (Music/Romance) - Love story between two musicians a great show.
School Days (Drama/Romance/Harem) - Deconstruction of shows where main char is oblivious to girls in love with him. Starts off cliche show one of the craziest endings you'll ever see.
Seitokai no Ichizon (Comedy) - A lot of anime related puns, funny.
Seto no Hanayome (comedy) - Funniest show I've ever seen.
Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann (Mecha/Action/Awesome) - Takes everything to extremes and becomes a ridiculous and awesome show.
Toradora! (Drama/Romance) - Enjoyable love story
Welcome to NHK! (slice of life/nerd romance?) - Weird story about a shut in that tries to make a hentai game with a friend and meets a girl.
Nichijou (slice of life) - Hilarious show based on fast paced gags and over the top reaction faces
Kaichou wa Maid-sama (comedy/romance) - Girl is the main char for once. Well done fun show.
Steins; Gate (Sci fic/Drama) - Holy shit this was so good. Time travel, great story, and very well written characters.
Bakemonogatari (Harem/supernatural) - a lot of dialogue interesting art style and a lot of word play/puns. Great show.
Fate Zero
Kimi ni Todoke (H.S. Romance) - cute love story.
Puella Madoka Magica (Magical girl deconstruction/drama) - first 3 eps are super cute sailor moon style then ep 3 shit gets real and real dark and crazy.
5 cm per second - Movie about guy/girl growing up growing apart kinda deep life lesson type stuff.


****Other shows I'd think you like****
Baka to Test to Shokanju (Comedy) - pretty funny show.
Afro Samurai (action) - Samuel Jackson is badass samurai plus wu-tang clan does soundtrack
Claymore (Action) - Dark/creepy feeling show that gets real good at ep 5
Full Metal Panic 2 season (Action) - Clueless guy who's pure trained killer has to fit in with HS girl cool show
Full Metal Panic Fumoffu (Comedy) - inbetween season that plays off story funny once u know the chars.
High School of the Dead (Action/Zombie) - Zombie survival show with hot chicks w/ unnecessarily large tits
The world only god knows 2 season - Kid expert and dating video games applies his skills to real girls. Fun show.